As an avid reader with a particular fondness for fantasy and stories about strong, complex women, the title “The Duncans” by Kirsten Miller immediately caught my attention. A tale of modern-day witches battling against the patriarchy sounded not only intriguing, but also exceptionally relevant in today’s world. With themes of empowerment and magic woven into the narrative, I was eager to dive in.
From the start, the book introduces us to Wild Hill, a place where nature’s powers linger and where the ghost of a witch murdered by colonists has kept the land haunted for centuries. I found this setting beautifully described and steeped in atmosphere, truly enhancing my reading experience. The concept of the Duncan family history and their generational gifts intrigued me, especially as it intertwined their destinies with the tragic past of their ancestor, Sadie Duncan.
The characterization was one of the book’s strong suits. Brigid, Phoebe, and Sybil each have complex personalities and backstories that reflect the burdens and gifts handed down through their lineage. I loved witnessing their growth as they faced their grievances and evolved into the powerful witches they were destined to become. The representation of family dynamics and the healing that can arise from confronting past issues resonated deeply with me.
However, there were aspects of the book that didn’t fully meet my expectations. While the world-building was compelling, I did find parts of the plot somewhat predictable. Many readers have expressed a desire for more surprises or twists, and I can understand this viewpoint. The theme of witches confronting the patriarchy is powerful, but there were times when the narrative followed a familiar trajectory that left me wishing for a more unexpected turn of events.
Another drawback is that while the characters were rich in potential, some of their arcs felt underexplored. For instance, Sybil, the seemingly powerless chef, had so many opportunities for development that I felt went unaddressed. As someone who enjoys in-depth character exploration, I wanted to see more of her journey toward discovering her true self in relation to her lineage.
Despite these drawbacks, I appreciated the book’s overall message: the importance of family, heritage, and the reconciliation between past and present. The blurb promised a “witty, spectacular, and timely tale,” and for the most part, it delivered on that. The witches’ war against humanity’s shortcomings has an urgency that mirrors present-day social issues, making it a thought-provoking read.
On the whole, “The Duncans” embraces the spirit of sisterhood and powerful women, which was one of the most uplifting elements of the story. As Brigid and Phoebe confronted their own lives while helping Sybil discover her heritage, I felt invested in their journey; it reinforced the idea that true strength lies in coming together.
In conclusion, I would recommend “The Duncans” primarily for fans of fantasy who enjoy stories about empowerment and family. Though it has its predictable moments and some character arcs that leave a bit to be desired, the blend of magic, social commentary, and strong female leads provides a rewarding experience. I would rate it 4 out of 5 stars for its heart, atmosphere, and compelling themes, while acknowledging that there is room for deeper exploration in future installments or related works. Overall, it’s a delightful read and an empowering reminder of the strength that lies within familial bonds.