"What is Strategy?: An Illustrated Guide to Michael Porter" – A Review
As someone who is fascinated by business literature, I was immediately intrigued by the title "What is Strategy?: An Illustrated Guide to Michael Porter." The blend of strategy and visual storytelling piqued my interest, especially with Joseph Magretta at the helms—her previous work, Understanding Michael Porter, had left a lasting impression on me. When I found out it presented foundational concepts in a graphic format, I knew it was something I had to dive into.
What stood out to me the most was the engaging narrative surrounding a fictional management team struggling to unify its strategy. With the help of the renowned Professor Porter, they work through concepts like industry structure, competitive advantage, and the Five Forces. These classic Porter frameworks are simplified to be digestible without losing their depth—something many readers, including John W. Pearson, appreciated by highlighting the “wow-factor” infused into an already robust topic. The humor sprinkled throughout—like a bull CFO quipping about sensitive jokes—adds a refreshing layer, making it much more than your typical business book.
On the positive side, the illustrations by Emile Holmewood are visually appealing and serve to clarify complex concepts. The way Magretta distills intricate ideas into easily digestible chunks is commendable. One could sense the enthusiasm in Mark Amtower’s review when he called it a groundbreaking work in business book literature. It’s not just a book; it’s an enjoyable experience that combines learning with laughter, and I couldn’t agree more.
However, no book is without its drawbacks. Some reviewers, like Shelia, pointed out that the content could sometimes feel too simplified, making it less suitable for deeper strategic analysis. While I appreciated the accessible approach, I could see how seasoned strategists might find themselves craving more depth. Furthermore, this book operates more as a primer rather than an exhaustive guide—if you’re looking for intensive scholarly analysis, you might need to look elsewhere.
Another aspect to consider is the book’s unique format—while many readers will love the comic-book-like style, others might find it less suited to their expectations of a traditional business book. A few, like SHK, mentioned its engaging and entertaining presentation but noted that it might not satisfy those in pursuit of rigorous academic frameworks.
In line with the official description, which states, "When it comes to strategy, the mistake most managers make is thinking they have one when they don’t," I found the narrative compelling. The scenarios presented offer relatable situations that many managers face, emphasizing the importance of developing a coherent strategy. I found myself reflecting on my own experiences, confirming that the illustrations and anecdotes resonate well with the intended audience.
Overall, I would rate this book 4.5 stars. It excels in its goal of simplifying complex strategy concepts and presents them in a fun, engaging manner. While seasoned professionals seeking depth may feel it falls short on occasion, the intended audience—be it new managers or those in need of a refresher—will find tremendous value in its pages.
In conclusion, I highly recommend "What is Strategy?" for anyone interested in building a solid foundational understanding of strategic management while enjoying a lighthearted read. Whether you’re preparing for your first strategy meeting or simply want a fresh take on business strategy, this book delivers an enjoyable journey through essential concepts. Find a comfy spot, grab a copy, and enjoy the ride!
“Unlock the Secrets of Business Success with This Illustrated Guide to Michael Porter’s Strategy” >>