Review of Still Life by Sarah Winman
As an avid reader and lover of historical fiction, I was immediately drawn to Still Life by Sarah Winman, especially after learning it was a Good Morning America Book Club Pick. The blend of love, war, and art set against the backdrop of Tuscany in 1944 is a recipe for a captivating read, and I was eager to dive into a story that promised both heart and depth.
The narrative begins with Ulysses Temper, a young English soldier who fortuitously encounters Evelyn Skinner, a middle-aged art historian, in the ruins of a villa during WWII. This chance meeting becomes pivotal, shaping Ulysses’s life for the next four decades. The prose flows beautifully, reflecting Winman’s rich storytelling skills that have garnered her praises from many readers. The intricate tapestry of characters and lively descriptions of Florence truly make this a love letter not just to the city but to the timeless human experiences of friendship and family.
Two aspects I particularly loved about Still Life were its profound character development and vibrant setting. Ulysses, Evelyn, and their companions feel like friends you’ve known for years. Their quirks and struggles resonate deeply, making this motley crew’s journey after the war heartwarming and engaging. Also, as someone who adores Italy, the rich, sensory details of Tuscan life were like a delightful stroll through the sun-drenched streets of Florence itself.
However, it’s essential to acknowledge some drawbacks, as noted by other readers. While many, including myself, found the writing style elegant and evocative, some pointed out the unconventional grammar and lack of quotation marks in dialogue. For instance, one reviewer mentioned finding the absence of quotation marks slightly off-putting, as it distanced them from the narrative. I found this stylistic choice initially perplexing, though I eventually adapted to it, allowing the prose to envelop me instead of distracting me. Additionally, the book’s pacing can be slow at times. I agree with those who felt it started a bit sluggishly. While the rich details are largely captivating, the story’s gradual unfolding can test the patience of some readers.
Despite these minor issues, the novel delivers a profound exploration of art, love, and the ties that bind us through even the darkest times. It underscores the significance of relationships formed amidst chaos, much like how Ulysses and Evelyn help each other navigate their lives. Winman’s portrayal of their journey is a beautiful reminder of resilience and the importance of creating family bonds with those we choose, rather than those we are born into.
In summary, Still Life is a captivating exploration that marries the beauty of art with the strength of human connection. It’s not a light or quick read, but rather a fulfilling experience that lingers long after the last page. I wholeheartedly recommend this novel to anyone who enjoys historical fiction, character-driven narratives, or tales that celebrate the enduring power of love and beauty.
Overall, I’m grateful I followed my instincts and chose to immerse myself in this beautifully woven story. It’s one that beckons for multiple readings, as I’m sure new layers will reveal themselves with each revisit. Whether you’re already a fan of Sarah Winman or venturing into her world for the first time, Still Life will undoubtedly leave its mark on your heart.