I recently finished Who Is Government? edited by Michael Lewis, and let me tell you, it was an eye-opening experience. I have always had a keen interest in non-fiction, particularly books that explore crucial societal themes. The premise of this book, focusing on the vital yet often overlooked work of public servants, piqued my interest immediately. I wanted to understand who these individuals are and how their contributions shape our daily lives.
Michael Lewis, known for his compelling storytelling, paired with an impressive array of writers—including Casey Cep and Dave Eggers—delivers narratives about public servants who often go unnoticed. I found the way these stories were woven together to be remarkably engaging. Lewis has a unique talent for zooming in on individual experiences while also painting a broader picture of our culture. Each chapter spots the bright light of dedication in the often-dim landscape of bureaucracy.
Several themes resonated with me, particularly those of resilience and selflessness in public service. For instance, Daniel Dellaferrera points out how the book serves as a vital shield against the vilification of government workers. Indeed, the authors present case studies that illuminate the honest, hard work of these employees, showcasing not just their professional lives but also their deep commitment to betterment—a viewpoint I wholeheartedly agree with.
However, the book isn’t without its critiques. According to some readers, like AK, certain narratives lean towards a "progressive" viewpoint, which may not sit well with everyone. I can see how this framing might prompt readers to feel that the authors could have presented a more balanced perspective regarding both the positives and negatives of government. While I appreciated the spotlight on hard-working public servants, I also recognize that a fair discussion about the challenges within government systems is important.
Additionally, while the stories were captivating, a few readers, including Jeffrey Roughgarden, voiced concern about how they could sometimes feel incomplete or lacking in broader context, especially regarding political implications and how they affect governmental operations today. I personally found the focus on the individual stories heartwarming, but I understand the desire for a more nuanced exploration of the system as a whole. A well-rounded discussion would have added even more depth to the already substantial profiles.
Yet, despite these drawbacks, I found the book significantly powerful and timely, especially considering our current socio-political climate. The urgent call for civics education couldn’t be more relevant, and as expressed in the Washington Post’s endorsement, it does indeed stand as “perhaps never before has there been a book better timed or more urgent.” Lewis and his team of writers have crafted essays that not only entertain but also inspire and educate, demonstrating how crucial government work can be in addressing society’s myriad issues.
In conclusion, Who Is Government? is a robust blend of inspiration and reality that shines a positive light on an often-maligned sector. It certainly met my expectations and offered much more: a call to recognize and appreciate the unsung heroes in our government. I recommend it not just for those who are curious about government operations but anyone with a larger interest in understanding societal functions. It’s a read that ultimately encourages a deeper appreciation for the people behind the scenes, the ones working diligently for the greater good. This book deserves a space on your shelf, especially if you’re keen on societal narratives that uplift and challenge perceptions.