As a devoted reader, I’m always on the lookout for the next compelling mystery, and Michael Connelly is one of those authors whose work never disappoints. When I heard about Nightshade, the first book featuring Detective Stilwell, I couldn’t resist diving in. Connelly’s novels are renowned for their intricate plots and well-drawn characters, so I was eager to see how he would introduce a new hero into his existing universe.
Set against the picturesque backdrop of Catalina Island, Nightshade follows Detective Stilwell, who is "exiled" to a quieter post after conflicts with colleagues on the mainland. What starts as a routine patrol quickly escalates when he discovers a body—identified only by a streak of purple dye in her hair—floating in the harbor. This case, alongside a report of poaching, pulls him into a web of corruption that reveals darker secrets under the island’s serene facade.
One of the standout elements for me was the vivid setting. Connelly’s depiction of Catalina Island was not merely a backdrop; it practically became a character itself. As noted by fellow readers like Nigelhein, the locations feel authentic, whether real or fictional. As someone who’s never been to Catalina, I found myself drawn into its details, making the island come alive through his descriptions.
Stilwell himself is an intriguing character. He embodies the classic qualities of a Connelly protagonist—relentless in his pursuit of justice, with a depth that hints at layers yet to unfold. I appreciated the pacing of the book; the story moves quickly, maintaining the tension that keeps you flipping pages, a familiar trait in Connelly’s writing. As Patrick S. Baker pointed out, while Stilwell may not yet rival Harry Bosch in terms of character development, he offers a refreshing perspective, particularly with his grounded persona and more relatable struggles.
However, the book is not without its drawbacks. Some readers, like Gary C., found the plot to be more predictable than Connelly’s usual work, pointing out that the bad guys felt somewhat obvious. I could see this perspective; while the narrative maintained my interest, it did lack the depth and twists that I’ve come to expect from Connelly’s best stories. As a connoisseur of crime fiction, I relish those unexpected turns that elevate a good story to an exceptional one.
Another minor letdown was the character development of Stilwell himself. Although I found him engaging, I can understand why some might feel he wasn’t as fleshed-out as Connelly’s other protagonists. That said, I believe this is typical of the first book in a series. An introduction often serves to set the stage and establish the character’s world before diving deeper into their psyche in subsequent installments, so I’m hopeful for his evolution in future books.
Overall, Nightshade proves to be a solid beginning for Stilwell’s story, balancing charm and suspense in a unique setting. The writing is sharp, the dialogue flows effortlessly, and the atmosphere is rich and engaging. Despite some predictable elements in the plot and a somewhat underdeveloped lead character, the book holds enough intrigue and potential to keep any Connelly fan invested.
In conclusion, I’d recommend Nightshade to both new readers and long-time fans. It’s an engaging mystery that sets the stage for what could be a thrilling series. If you enjoy a mix of action, a touch of corruption, and a hint of character exploration, give Stilwell a chance. I’m looking forward to seeing where Connelly takes this new detective next, and I would not hesitate to pick up his next installment.
Discover the thrilling world of mystery and intrigue in Nightshade. >>